Pin it
This lobster roll recipe combines the best of both worlds with buttery lobster meat folded into a lemony mayonnaise dressing, giving you the perfect balance between Connecticut and Maine styles in every bite.
I first made these lobster rolls for a backyard gathering when fresh lobster was out of my budget. My guests couldn't believe they weren't made with fresh caught Maine lobster, and now it's my go-to impressive yet simple summer meal.
Ingredients
- Lobster meat: Frozen or from fresh lobsters provides the sweet tender base for this sandwich choose high quality meat without tears or discoloration
- Celery: Adds necessary crunch and freshness to balance the rich lobster
- Mayonnaise: Creates the creamy binding sauce use a good quality brand for best results
- Chives: Bring a delicate onion flavor without overpowering the delicate lobster
- Lemon juice and zest: Brighten the entire dish and cut through the richness
- Kosher salt: Enhances all flavors use this larger grain salt for better flavor control
- Split top brioche buns: Provide the perfect buttery vessel look for authentic New England style for traditional presentation
- Butter: Is essential for both cooking the lobster and toasting the buns use unsalted for better control of seasoning
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Prepare the lobster:
- Thoroughly check thawed lobster meat for any shell fragments by spreading pieces on a plate and examining carefully. Drain completely using a colander and even pat with paper towels to remove excess moisture which would make your filling watery. Tear into chunks about the size of a quarter for the perfect texture in each bite.
- Make the mayo mixture:
- Combine all sauce ingredients in a large bowl ensuring the celery is minced finely and evenly. The mayonnaise should just barely coat the ingredients not overwhelm them. This base can be made up to 4 hours ahead and refrigerated for convenience.
- Butter cook the lobster:
- Heat a skillet until medium hot but not smoking then add butter and let it melt completely before adding lobster. Keep the lobster moving constantly while cooking to ensure even butter coating without overcooking the delicate meat. The goal is warming not cooking as the lobster is already cooked.
- Toast the buns:
- Wipe the skillet clean of any lobster residue before adding fresh butter for toasting. Place buns cut side down and press lightly to ensure full contact with the buttered surface. Watch carefully as the brioche toasts quickly usually needing only about 90 seconds to achieve golden perfection.
- Assemble and serve:
- Gently fold the warm buttery lobster into the mayonnaise mixture rather than stirring to maintain the chunks. Divide mixture evenly between toasted buns mounding slightly in the center for presentation. Serve immediately while still warm for the best flavor experience.
Pin it
My favorite part of this recipe is the moment when the warm buttery lobster hits the cool lemony mayo mixture. It reminds me of summers in New England when my family would stop at roadside seafood shacks. The first bite always transports me back to those carefree vacation days with the ocean breeze and the sound of seagulls.
Mastering Your Lobster Roll Texture
The secret to a perfect lobster roll lies in the texture contrast. The exterior of your bun should be crisp and buttery while the interior stays soft. Toast only the cut sides leaving the outside of the bun pillowy. This creates the perfect vessel for holding your lobster mixture. When preparing the lobster itself aim for chunks large enough to give that satisfying meaty bite. Shredded lobster disappears texturally while overly large pieces make the sandwich difficult to eat. Think quarter sized pieces for the perfect balance.
Making Ahead Options
While lobster rolls are best enjoyed immediately after preparation you can prep components ahead of time. The mayonnaise mixture can be combined up to 4 hours before serving and stored covered in the refrigerator. The lobster can be cleaned and chopped up to 6 hours ahead but should be stored separately from the mayo mixture. Toast the buns just before serving as they lose their crisp texture when held too long. For entertaining assemble a build your own lobster roll bar with toasted buns warm buttered lobster and the mayo mixture so guests can customize to their preference.
Regional Variations Worth Trying
This recipe intentionally blends two beloved regional styles but you might enjoy exploring each tradition separately. For authentic Connecticut style skip the mayonnaise mixture entirely and simply toss warm lobster meat in melted butter with a squeeze of lemon. Serve on a toasted roll for a pure buttery experience. For classic Maine style omit the butter cooking step and fold cold lobster directly into the mayonnaise mixture. Each style has passionate defenders and regional nuances worth exploring if you become a lobster roll enthusiast.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What type of lobster meat is best?
Freshly cooked lobster meat is ideal, but thawed frozen lobster meat also works wonderfully. Opt for large chunks for the best texture.
- → Can I use regular hot dog buns?
While New England-style split-top rolls are traditional, regular hot dog buns can be used. Trim the sides for a better toasting surface.
- → How do I ensure the lobster meat stays flavorful?
Cook the lobster meat in butter briefly to infuse it with richness. Be careful not to overcook, as it may dry out.
- → What pairs well with these lobster rolls?
Potato chips are a classic side, but coleslaw, a light salad, or even a bowl of clam chowder complement the rolls perfectly.
- → Can I prepare this ahead of time?
Yes, prepare the mayo mixture and cook the lobster meat ahead of time, but combine just before serving for the freshest taste.